Talk:CJ Hook/@comment-26267290-20160727121235/@comment-27418159-20161014084911

Technically we do not know if Ben approves of CJ or not he kind of never got the chance to see if she was like her dad or not plus it would be kind of to form his opinion of her when she was hidden half the time and when he was tied up. Because the villain kids only get redeemed if they are not like their parents and want to be good.no one really knows how CJ completely feels about her dad besides the fact he never lets her steer the ship. He might not suck at being a father/parent unlike Maleficent,Cruella,Jafar,The evil Queen,Dr Facilier,Diego's Parent(Or parents),Horace&Jasper,Basically everyone whose descendant(or descendants)joined the Anti heroes club in the second book because their kids want to be good and not evil after seeing that good really is stronger than evil. Dr facilier can't even remember his own kid's birthday and That is more sadder than not letting a kid steer a ship. CJ Hook probably gets loved by her father unlike all the villian kids who are feeling unloved by their parents like Mal,Evie,Carlos,Jay,Freddie,Hermie bing,Haddie,Claudine,Harold(Harry son of Horace),Jason(Jace son of Jasper),Diego De vil, Yzla,Big Murph,Yen Sid(Founder of the anti heroes club),and Eddie.the tv series never really says how Ben feels about CJ after what happened at the neon lights ball and it depends on how Captain Hook treats CJ despite not letting her steer a ship. And it also depends on if CJ wants to be good or stay evil.her future/fate is not really completely stated in the first school of secrets book. Plus no one knows how she feels about being bad she might like it or she might not like it.nothing is ever really specific with CJ she was hidden up until the neon lights ball so Ben has kind of not had enough time to form an overall opinion of her based on completely meeting her like he has with Mal,Evie,Carlos,Jay&Freddie. Heck he has barely met CJ to form an opinion at least with Freddie he knows a lot more about her than he does about CJ. CJ said we don't have to be like our parents then Mal said exactly we make our own choices.but CJ has never completely said what she wants her future to be like.her future for good or evil is kind of unknown since she is neutral/bad. CJ being redeemed depends on her overall opinion how she feels about being evil. Ben did say only the villian descendants who need auradon's help the most are given a chance to be redeemed.CJ probably has not reached the needing auradon's help the most part yet. just Mal,Evie,Carlos,Jay,Freddie,&a the members of the anti hero club have reached that stage. Ben said "We start with a few at first only the ones who need our help the most"(meaning those who are unhappy with being evil.) and CJ at the end of the first school of secrets book when Freddie mentions CJ staying in auradon and Ben letting CJ enroll at auradon prep,CJ responds with thanks but I don't think I'm really cut out for the whole prep school life too many rules. Then she says besides my next adventure awaits me. Plus CJ probably has not spent enough time being evil to know if she hates it or likes it to know what makes her rudely happy. Because right now she was raised to be bad even if she has some good in her we do not know which side of her stronger it might be her good side or it might be her evil side we do not know so it might be a very long time before we see her at auradon prep if she even ends up there. Her fate is unknown.