Thread:Alex2424121/@comment-13983026-20130924193358/@comment-16811522-20131012210739

Alex2424121 wrote:

InspiredAndNatural wrote: That didn't make any sense. And you still didn't explain anything. You said you'll believe what you know, which is in the novel, but what about what is also in the novel/film? I had given a few reasons on why I will continue to believe he's not a villain, and this cannot be ignored forever. You can't judge a person by one thing they do. You have to look at before and after. He even reasoned with the Duke when the Duke told him Anna may be conspiring with Elsa to destroy them. Hans wrongly assumed, after that conversation, that Elsa did something to Anna after the horse came back emptyhanded. Anna told him that Elsa directly struck her with her powers, which is not true (Elsa wanted to protect Anna). Because of them, he seemed to become suddenly evil, thinking that the only way was to kill Elsa. He then had a change of heart, shockingly stating "B-but she froze your heart." Just forget I ever wrote that.

I've already found out a lot more in the past few weeks. There are more leaked pages from the novel about Hans and its written he tries to kill off Elsa and leaves Anna to freeze so he can become the king of Arendelle and at the end he gets sent back to his kingdom in a cage for his behaviour. Its all on the web right now if you want to check it out. That's what I meant. Er,....it never said he was in a cage, (it mentioned that he was to be shipped back to the Southern Isles where his 12 older brothers would hear about his happenings), and he never said about ruling Arendelle. Hans only said, in his conversation with the Duke that I had already mentioned, that Anna had him in charge and he wouldn't hesitate to protect Arendelle. Anyways, he thought the only thing to do was kill Elsa because of what he was told by Anna. He thought he had good reasons for killing Elsa, as Elsa supposedly (even from Anna's mouth) freezed her heart, which would kill her. But another thing I don't understand is how he went from being against the Duke's assumptions and wanting to protect Arendelle, to being evil and leaving Anna to die, then being guilty for what he had tried to do. From my understanding of his last words in the book, he thought he had good reasons for killing Elsa; you know about the 'soul for soul' thing, right?