Talk:Alice Through the Looking Glass/@comment-4991841-20160612035633/@comment-27754500-20160612154755

Linda Woolverton can't write anymore. She only got it right with Beauty and the Beast. Everything else she did, didn't turn out good. She got to write some movies later (Alice in Wonderland 1 & 2, Maleficent) and she ruined them. The story felt better than in the first movie to me, but still way too complicated, with characters & messages appearing and then dissapearing.

As for the actors, Wasikowska did an important improvement on her acting, Cohen was wonderful and Carter was just how I wanted her to be. Depp felt a little more mad than he should be. Hathaway had her most meh performance ever.

I have to agree than the film is a visual masterpiece. It is also a wonderful experience in 3D and IMAX. Bobin did his best with directing it. I liked the more colorful style. But the script and some of the perfromances made this film an "okay" film to me, just like the first one.