Talk:Mulan (2020 film)/@comment-27373870-20180728212006/@comment-27373870-20180803152406

1. Niki Caro and Mulan production team removed Mushu, cricket, Li-shang... then re-create a new story for live action Mulan. As a Chinese-Vietnamese person, I can tell that's a right choice. I like the animated one, but the story has so many culture mistakes and the way they tell that story is too western to adapt into live action form. In this case, the best thing you can do if you want to make a cultural authenticity film is re-create it. You asked for talking dragon in a live-action wuxia film - that proves you know nothing about Chinese culture, you just can't understand the way we feel. A marriage of styles what? that sounds stupid, but "reflections" and "I'll make a man out of you" as credit songs sounds great.

2. Soldiers came to respect Mulan, sure, after she proves herself by taking the arrow. I think we don't share a same way in using our imagination.

3. Why should he believe someone who just lied to him? - Lie to who? Mulan breaks the law to save her father, She does that before she meets Shang. If breaking a sexist-law hurts something, it must be a sexist's feeling. Shang's still a freaking jerks anyway lol, just look they way he tells Mulan to go home at the Imperial City, Mulan deserves a better man than that, a man who takes her as she is.

5. In this case, a drastic one is better. Shan-yu is not a name, it's a title, so you can say the second villain, Bori Khan is shan-yu, and yeah, in this new version, he has a back story.