Talk:Anna/@comment-16811522-20131026004554

You didn't read anything I said. If he's the villain, what can you say about that conversation with the Duke, and his assumption of Elsa harming Anna at seeing her horse return without her? And the book says he stammered: "B-but she froze your heart," which is the last thing he says in the book. Anna told him that Elsa harmed her, which Elsa didn't even know herself as it was unintentional, and so he did not have the exact truth. You do know about the 'soul for soul' thing, right? His last words bring me to think he thought he had good reasons for killing her. With those last words and the thought of his 12 older brothers hearing of his behavior is guilt, don't you think? That's what small children feel too, and I've experienced it with my own mistakes. The Duke at the end claimed he was innocent, whereas he wasn't, and that's not guilt.