Talk:Lily Page/@comment-25140297-20150310163751

This is pure speculation, but I theorize that Lilith might be Malificent's lost child mentioned in season 4, Episode 14 Unforgiven. This is purely speculation, but I really think we were shown Emma meeting Lilly for a reason, and like Neal turning out to be Baelfire, I don't think we would focus on anyone specific from Emma's past if they weren't important in the future.

Snow White only mentions that Maleficent lost her baby, not that it died. Perhaps what they meant that it was banished to another world, not killed. Besides, Ursula and Cruella ended up in the real world outside of Storybrooke, outside of the curse somehow, perhaps all 3 were banished to Earth at the same time? Also, doesn't Lilith sound likes it's the kind of name Maleficent would name her daughter?