Talk:Hans/@comment-24354694-20140622134900/@comment-1416077-20140623005319

His leaving Arandelle at all is more than generous.

His leaving alive is extraordinary.

This shows an extraordinary degree of kindness on the part of Elsa.

Whether he repents or not, is redeemed or not, his acts make trusting him to any serious degree impossible. Trust is implicit in friendship. If you can't trust someone, you can't truly become his friend and you certainly cannot be close enough to have a romantic interest in him.

You also forget the basic tenets of True Love in Disney Princess films; the princess KNOWS that "he is the one"; Snow White and her Prince, Prince Charming and Cinderella, Aurora and Phillip, Ariel and Eric... Even if they initially dislike them, there is still a spark of charm (Tiana). When Elsa meets Hans, there is nothing there. In every one of their meetings; nothing there.

And before anyone mentions Anna and Kristoff... there IS a spark, but she was distracted by her infatuation with Hans, which she confused with true love.

Wow; I just realized that if Elsa hooked up with Hans, Anna would hit the roof! He lied to her, broke her heart, tried to kill her, left her to die, tried to kill her sister... AND THEN seduces her sister? the same one his confessed plan saw murdered?

No. I'm sorry. I can actually see Hans redeeming himself; likely in a very tragic, very terminal dramatic scene, but I do not see him, under ANY circumstances that make the remotest bit of sense, ending up as Elsa's "happily ever after".

I'd sooner ship Aladdin and Megara. It makes more sense.