Talk:Admiral Boom and Mr. Binnacle/@comment-26536288-20181212172703/@comment-1767212-20190311171101

Lots of cases happened in voice acting for live-actions.

Examples:

* David Prowse was unable to speak withouth his Cockney accent while in the suit of Darth Vader, so instead remained silent and Vader's voice was supplied by James Earl Jones and his baritone yet sinister tone for villains.

* Same thing with Ray Park. He probably couldn't made a sinister speech as his voice isn't so deep to fit with Darth Maul, so Peter Serafinowicz made the lipsynch for the Maul character.

So a possible theory is that Barclay's voice wasn't too deep or Binnacle, and that's the reason why Tomlinson instead made the dialogues of the character.