After watching a scary movie about dolls called Betty Die Time, Zuri refuses to sleep in her room again. Jessie tells her to face her fear, revealing her own fear as well: Porta-Potties. Meanwhile, Luke teaches Ravi how to impress a girl from his biology class, not yet realizing that Tanya has a crush on Luke, not Ravi, after she gives him a rib-cracking hug. Ignoring the context, Ravi is angry and upset because he thinks Luke betrayed him by "moving in on his woman" and challenges his brother to an unnecessary duel two hours later. During all of that mayhem, Bertram attempts to enter an opera contest to win a long vacation to Italy. While Luke and Ravi hit each other with large bread sticks, Bertram finds out that he did win, but not a vacation to Italy. After Luke "grinds" Ravi with sausage, Luke tells him what really happened two hours ago in Central Park and Ravi apologizes for not believing him in the first place. Finally, Emma solemnly tells Tanya that she would rather end up as an old maid with lots of cats than continue being her friend. In the end, after receiving weird dreams about their greatest fears, Zuri and Jessie successfully conquer them.