After Paige convinces the volleyball coach to put Amelia on the team, the DIY Diva's ego lands the volleyball team in a match against the state champions.
Amelia is initially excited to try out for the Sierra High School volleyball team until she learns she may have to work hard to be accepted by Coach Carlson. Paige trains Amelia and motivates her to try her best rather than give up. Later, Paige learns that Carlson has rejected Amelia, and that he is also at risk of being fired. Paige arranges a deal with him to save his job in exchange for him letting Amelia onto the team. Amelia, still inspired by Paige, challenges the state volleyball champion team to a match. Sierra High School's volleyball team loses to the champion team, and Paige reveals to Amelia that she was not actually accepted by Carlson. Amelia says she is glad that Paige pushed her to try hard. Meanwhile, Frankie discovers that Bernie had written a graphic novel, and she is surprised to find how good it is. However, she is disappointed to learn that Bernie never wrote the ending, so she makes him write it.