Andrew Hornby A cool, popular kid at school with brown hair and a dark voice is Irma's secret crush. In the comics, Irma tries to get him to like her by transforming herself to make her look older and prettier, but this plan backfires and she ends up turning him into a toad. He is a little bit older than her and in the higher grades, but Irma and Andrew do have a weak relationship. He has only appeared in "L is for Loser" but was mentioned in "C is for Changes".
Irma has tried to flirt with him by making her body look more mature using her magic, but that backfired when she turned him into a toad for days out of nervousness when he tried to kiss her.
- "C is for Changes" (mentioned)
- "L is for Loser" (first appearance)
- "T is for Trauma"
- "W is for Witch"