Captain Hook notices that his prized hooks are filthy. He orders Sharky and Bones to clean them. While Sharky and Bones tend to the hooks, the octopus creeps aboard, and steals the eight hooks from Sharky and Bones, then slips back into the Never Sea, with Sharky and Bones in pursuit, fearing the fate Hook will have them in when he discovers that his hooks are missing. Mr. Smee tries to stall Hook until Sharky and Bones recover the hooks. They chase the Octopus to Neverland. When they lose sight of The Octopus, they run into Jake and his crew, who offer to help Sharky and Bones retrieve the hooks.
While searching the island, the pirates encounter The Octopus soaring through the sky, using the "Whirly-hook" they later retrieve, said hook when The Octopus makes another round by climbing up a palm tree. Later, The Octopus tries to evade the pirates, using the Fishing Rod-Hook to climb up a cliff face out of the pirate's reach, but Jake manages to outwit the slippery cephalopod, using the Whirly-hook, retrieved earlier, to beat The Octopus to the top of the cliff and retrieve both the fishing rod and butterfly net hook, and a few other hooks, before The Octopus flees down to the beach. Using the Shovel-Hook, The Octopus conceals himself by building a giant sandcastle. When the pirates reach the beach, they discover the sandcastle became very suspicious, and with a closer inspection of the castle, Izzy spots one of the octopus tentacles poking out of the castle. Cubby quickly uses the Feather-Hook to tickle the Octopus into submission, allowing the other pirates to retrieve the remaining hooks before flying back to the Jolly Roger with Izzy's pixie dust.
With hooks returned to Hook's cabinet, Sharky and Bones thank Jake and his crew, who then fly back to Pirate Island. However in the mix of getting the hooks back, the hooks are even more filthy when Captain Hook ordered to clean them. Sharky and Bones are now forced to walk the plank, but are luckily caught by the Octopus down below, who bounces them on his tentacles for fun. Smee joins in the fun, and Hook, deciding to forgive them, surprisingly joins in on the fun, too.
- Jake and his crew collect eight gold doubloons.
- Colin Ford as Jake
- Madison Pettis as Izzy
- Jonathan Morgan Heit as Cubby
- David Arquette as Skully
- Corey Burton as Captain Hook
- Jeff Bennett as Mr. Smee
- Loren Hoskins as Sharky
- Jeff Bennett (speaking)/Kevin Hendrickson (singing) as Bones
- Dee Bradley Baker as The Octopus