When Cory looks in Meena's notebook, he sees a heart around her name and the initials C.B. Cory thinks she has a crush on him, but instead Meena has a crush on a guy named Craig Berkowitz.
Meena asks for Cory's advice on how to get to Craig to ask her out, so they pretend to be a couple, however, Stickler believes they really are a couple and decides to ruin their fake date.
Meanwhile, Sophie develops a crush on Newt and invites him over for a tea party.
- Kyle Massey as Cory Baxter
- Jason Dolley as Newt Livingston III
- Maiara Walsh as Meena Paroom
- Madison Pettis as Sophie Martinez
- John D'Aquino as President Richard Martinez
- Rondell Sheridan as Victor Baxter
- David Boller as Abe Lincoln
- Jake Thomas as Jason Stickler
- Jarron Vosburg as Craig Berkowitz