The v-loggers have to make a scary Halloween video for Vuuugle's homepage, but they can't decide whose video is the scariest - Frankie and Paige's tale of the ghost of Hollander Prep, Dirk's haunting world without dares, or Amelia's zombie apocalypse.
On Halloween, Liam is asking Paige, Frankie, Dirk, Amelia, and Bernie for a Halloween video idea to post on Bizaardvark's main page. Each one does their Halloween video pitch:
- Paige and Frankie's story takes place at Hollander Prep where they are haunted by the ghost of Hollander Prep's founder.
- Dirk's story deals with a dystopian future where dares are outlawed.
- Amelia's story deals with a new shampoo turning everyone into zombie-like Ameliacs.
After the stories are pitched, Liam ends up going with the Halloween video that Horse Face Guy just posted of him in a skeleton costume. In the final scene, Bernie tells his story after being disappointed with dying in each one. While claiming in the story that is invincible, he is zapped by Liam in the story who then quotes to the viewers "Happy Halloween!"