Jane continues to shadow Mal into the Museum of Cultural History, being very careful that she does not spot her. Jane nearly gets caught when a Magic Broom jumps off its display and roams loose in the museum, nearly knocking down one of the exhibits, but she manages to catch the broom and hide in a nearby storeroom before Mal spots here. Once it is safe, she comes out of hiding and spots Mal stealing Jafar's Snake Staff. Mal leaves the museum with the staff and gives it to someone waiting under the bleachers while Jane goes back to tell the others.
Mal returns to her dorm where she is confronted by her friends. They know from Jane that she broke into the museum which Mal deny, only for Jane to admit that she followed her there. Mal scares Jane away. Evie tries to confront her friend, but Mal tries to push her away which results in her losing the necklace Freddie gave her. The necklace hits the floor and breaks, revealing Mal's jewel inside. Mal angrily tries to take it back, but Evie tosses it to Jay who threatens to throw it out the window. Then suddenly Mal returns to normal, feeling very confused. Her friends tell her about the horrible things she did and deduce that her jewel is cursed. Whenever Mal is close to it, it makes her evil. Mal is left shocked and ashamed about the things she unknowingly did. Although Evie disliked the way Mal treated her and her friends, she still forgives her as she knew from the start that she was not herself. Mal thanks Evie for believing in her and the two friends hug each other.
While it may seem that everything is back to normal, the stranger Mal met under the bleachers meanwhile breaks into Geppetto's Workshop with an evil plan take over Auradon.
- Dove Cameron as Mal
- Sofia Carson as Evie
- Brenna D'Amico as Jane
- Booboo Stewart as Jay
- Cameron Boyce as Carlos De Vil
- Bradley Steven Perry as Zevon
- In the Museum of Cultural History there are more items that represent different Disney Films.
- Mal does not remember anything that happened while she was cursed.
- This episode was originally titled "Steal Away" but when it premiered it was retitled "Evil Among Us", and retitled back to "Steal Away" several days later on Youtube, along with a leaked possible synopsis for the next episode.