In Castillo Park, a short man arrives on a huge black horse. He then pulls out a guitar and uses it to put everyone in the park under a spell. The man is a bandit named Tito. He robs all of the entranced people. he then takes off to rob more people. Meanwhile, at Avalor Palace, Francisco and Luisa head out to the beach. Isabel's friends arrive not long afterward. Isabel has a new invention that she made for Cristina: The Super Chair, a wheelchair that has all kinds of gadgets. Isabel wants to try them all out but Cristina wants to take it slow. Elena agrees with her by telling Isabel people to need to do things their own way. Suddenly, an alarm goes off. Isabel explains that it's the alarm system she invented for Elena's team so they would know there's an emergency. Isabel heads to where Elena's team is meeting. At the meeting, Gabe tells them about the bandit and they all set off.
They arrive in Castillo Park and confront Tito. Unfortunately, Elena, Mateo, Gabe, and Naomi get put under Tito's spell too. Isabel, who was left behind, retreats back to Avalor Palace. Isabel's friends are playing in the courtyard when Oliva arrives for her lesson with Mateo. Isabel arrives back and tells her friends what happened. The four of them agree to help her. Isabel comes up with an Elena themed plan. Despite tripping over each other, the plan works. Quique, Amara, and Olivia are thrilled the plan worked but Cristina points out that that was just a one time only fluke. Tito reappears and Isabel comes up with another Elena themed plan. Unfortunately, the plan backfires because they just trip over each other again. After Quique blurts out that Elena's the Crown Princess, Tito decides to use Elena to help him rob the Royal Treasury.
The others ask Isabel what the plan is now. Isabel tells them she can't come up with another Elena themed plan. Cristina tells Isabel that she should think what Isabel would do, not what Elena would do. Isabel comes up with a new plan and it works because they play to their strengths this time. Tito is apprehended just as Francisco and Luisa return. Francisco takes Tito's broken guitar back inside to be repaired, much to his granddaughters' horror.
- Aimee Carrero as Princess Elena
- Jenna Ortega as Princess Isabel
- Julia Vera as Luisa
- Emiliano Díez as Francisco
- Montse Hernandez as Cristina
- Anthony Ramos as Tito the Magical Bandit
- Jillian Rose Reed as Naomi Turner
- Jorge Diaz as Gabe
- Joseph Haro as Mateo
- Kitana Turnbull as Olivia
- Zoe Hendrix as Amara
- Kyle Arem as Quique
- "When Tito So Sweetly Sings"
- "More, More, More"
- When Olivia asked Isa how she can conjure or do her magic, Isa responded to what Elena sang to Mateo in the song "The Magic Within You" from the episode "Spellbound".
- Moral: When solving a problem, it is best to solve it your own way instead of someone else's way