The show appears to be a spectacle of rivalry between the Pumpkinmen and Pink Witches, hosted by Minnie Mouse and Stitch, to determine which camp of Halloween mischief should be declared winner of the season with Maleficent and the Disney Villains. Guests clap, dance and tap their feet to the music and songs, before laughing (for the Pumpkinmen) or screeching (for the Pink Witches) to determine the winner.
In 2008, the show changed a lot. Since Stitch and the Pink Witches were removed, the contest was cancelled. However, Governor Ratcliffe and Shan Yu joined the show. In 2010, Maleficent was replaced by Dr. Facilier in the show.