After going trick-or-treating, JoJo, Goliath, Skeebo, Trina and Croaky pay a visit to Clownfoot Lodge to hear Mr. Tickle's annual telling of the legend of Clownfoot. This spooky interactive story lets the listener play along by adding sound effects such as the howling of wind and knocking at a door. Viewers practice silly faces with JoJo to keep from being too scared and then need them when suddenly the lights go out. Skeebo is delighted, though, as he's been hoping to get a photo of the real Clownfoot. Trina dismisses the idea, saying that there's no such thing. After the lights are turned back on, the kids following a trail and start searching for clues. They make a surprising discovery as to what caused the lights to go out, the trail they're following, and the eerie moaning noises they've been hearing.