Alex2424121 wrote:
This is going to ruin everything we've worked so hard to create. Never will I accept this and never will I support it.
I really enjoyed that movie, it was great and I showed no care about the differences what so ever but now you've all let logic and accuracy ruin it all which now threatens the way this Wikia has been created for the past few years. Is this how its going to be when Disney introduces the villains in Descendants or introduce them in their own movies, or when that planned film Cruella comes out, let logic and accuracy ruin it all? If so then what's the point of being here?
You're not like most people, though. I'm willing to bet the average joe, if they came to this wiki and saw Maleficent's page and saw that she was both redeemed and irredeemable in the category section, they'd be confused as heck.
And besides, there are plenty of wikis relating to large franchises that do multiple articles of the same character anyhow. I'll even give you a shortlist:
Superman Rebirth
Batman
Marvel Database
Resident Evil
Final Fantasy Wiki (kind of, both the main heroes and the main villains of each installment have two articles, three if we count quotes lists, one for their main appearance, and one for their appearance in Dissidia).
Those are the examples that came to my head, with some help. They weren't particularly terrible. Heck, technically speaking, Wookieepedia is doing the same thing with its primary characters, ironically thanks to the continuity mess caused by Disney's merger, and Mega Man Knowledge Network (the Mega Man Wiki) is doing something similar with Archie Comics. Sonic Wiki is doing just that with the Archie, SATAM, Underground, Game, and Sonic Boom universes as well. Last I checked, none of those wikis are particularly terrible, though hey, don't hear it from me, just look at those wikis if you don't believe me.
Just follow the above links to see what I mean. And besides, if that's your problem, you're definitely not going to like the Burton Wonderland separate articles on this wiki anyways as some people have pointed out.